
I bought Mississippi Secrets at a Barnes and Noble in Biloxi because the authors (Dr Gary McDowell and Ruth McDowell) were having a signing there. I figured I might as well support a local author.
The book itself is average and not overly impressive. The narrative is easy to follow but not very deep. This shallowness is not always a problem, especially if that's what you want. For better or worse, the best word to describe this book is "folksy."
I did enjoy the sections about the Native Americans in Mississippi because I didn't know their legends or myths. The section about Holt Collier (the former slave who found a bear for Teddy Roosevelt) gives a different perspective about the Teddy Bear incident that I had not heard. The McDowells' description of the Jim Bowie's knife fight near Natchez was also interesting and read more like a short story than like a history book. For me, the most interesting part of the book was the personal interview with James Meredith, the first African American to attend Ole Miss. At the time, Governor Ross Barnett was adamantly opposed to James Meredith enrolling into a white university. Gary McDowell asked, "How did you feel when Ross Barnett got up in your face and started yelling like he did?" James Meredith answered:
Well, you see, I was not just a soldier. I was a politician also. I always had a good deal of respect for Governor Barnett. I knew that what he was doing was not aimed against me. [...] You see, the whites in Mississippi were as restricted by the rules of White Supremacy as the blacks were, and not a single black was hurt during all those years I was involved in that in Mississippi. I credit Governor Barnett for that. I gave him almost total credit for being the one that kept the blacks from being hurt. He deliberately kept he whites under his hand, kept them believing he was going to take care of the problem so that they wouldn't go out hurting, shooting, lynching or whatever. [...] So actually, I always considered him mostly on my side. I thought that he wanted change in Mississippi just as much as I wanted change. But he knew there were certain processes that had to take place before full citizenship could be established after the system had been in place for more than 100 years. (118-119)
During the interview, James Meredith also said that whites lynched other whites who had broken the White Supremacy Rules. His responses fascinated me, and it's very insightful. I'm not sure if Ross Barnett deserves such a kind critique, but this answer would make a great prompt for a political science class discussion.
However, there were parts of the book I did not enjoy. The UFO story did not deserve to be in this book. The entire chapter about famous Mississippians could have been omitted. I'm sick of hearing about which famous actors and singers are from Mississippi. Faith Hill, 3 Doors Down, Lacey Nicole Chabert, Morgan Freeman, Elvis Presley, Afroman, Lance Bass, Oprah Winfrey, Jimmy Buffett, BB King, and LeAnn Rimes DO NOT make Mississippi special or important. I know that last sentence was probably blasphemous. I'm surprised this chapter does not include any famous Mississippi writers. This chapter would have been better if the McDowells had told Faulkner's and Welty's life story and contribution to literature. At least those two (unlike many they do mention) actually stayed in Mississippi.
They said Katrina was the most powerful storm ever in the Gulf of Mexico with 175 mph winds, but Camille had 190 mph winds. We simply don't know and never will know how powerful Camille was (including the storm surge's exact height). Katrina was a much broader storm with weaker winds, but this does not make Katrina the "most powerful storm ever in the Gulf of Mexico." I understand that the Katrina vs Camille debate can be very contentious, especially since Katrina memories are fresh and salient.
A couple other things bothered me about the book. For instance, they confuse Ole Miss with Mississippi State University. They aren't the same. The Bibliography showed they used 9 sources from Wikipedia, which is an academic taboo. There are also some grammatical problems. For instance, in Chapter 6 they use two spellings (Hinds and Hines) for the same man. I blame the publisher and editor for this sloppiness.
I hate speaking ill about certain parts of this book after reading Gary and Ruth's personal story in the last chapter. Dr Gary had been a history teacher in the public school system until 2005 when a student assaulted him in the classroom. Due to his injuries, he could not return to work and lost a lot of his vision. I could not infer if he was in a wheelchair before or after this attack. Later that year Katrina flooded their home, so Ruth had to pull up the carpet and make repairs without Gary's help. After the storm Gary dictated to Ruth this book since he could not see well enough. I'm impressed with anyone who dictates a book while blind.
Overall, I'd say Gary and Ruth wrote a descent, folksy retelling of Mississippi history with only a couple slight yet forgivable errors.