After flying into Houston about three weeks ago, I quickly realized I was back in Texas when I scrolled through the various country, Christian, and tejano radio stations. Even though I grew up in the buckle of the Bible belt, I'm still surprised to hear so many Christian radio stations in Houston. I even recently heard that one of the Christian stations here is raising funds to start a new youth Christian radio station. I'm not sure how contemporary Christian music for youth would be much different than contemporary Christian music for adults.
Truth is, I don't really like contemporary Christian music, which I know is heresy to say amongst my generation in today's church. I like my lyrics to have more than 10 words repeated over and over. For me, today's style is too emotional and without depth. Sometimes the poetry in hymns written in the 1800s (or more recently) can blow me away with their depth and imagery. The complexity and intelligence of God is beautiful. I understand that contemporary Christian music is trying to reach a broader audience and thus simplifies the lyrics in order to make the music more accessible. I'm ok with having different types or styles of Christianity in order to reach different people, but I feel like the church often forgets that there are young Christians who want depth in their worship. Granted, there's probably not enough of us to fill out huge auditoriums or spend money on CDs, but we're still here.
Though I don't like most of the contemporary worship music, there is some that I do like. For instance, I like most of "How He Loves," which I first heard a little more than a year ago at church when I lived in Mississippi. I like the imagery of God's love as a hurricane and us as a tree bending under His mercy. However, when we first sang it at church, the music leader used the lyrics "so heaven meets earth like a sloppy wet kiss" in the middle of the song. At this point, all my friends and I stopped singing and looked awkwardly at each other. Some of us chuckled. Perhaps that was childish, but we weren't expecting to sing "sloppy wet kiss" at church. From then on out, we called this song the "sloppy-wet-kiss song." These lyrics ruined the song for me because the metaphor gives me a horrible image. Sloppy wet kisses remind me of awkward youth romances (or lack thereof). My sister said it sounded like a gross kiss from a creepy uncle. Worst of all, we're singing this in unison at church. When I first heard this song, I was singing with guys and girls I went to college with, and there had been enough romances or attempted romances within this circle of friends that there had been some shared sloppy wet kisses amongst us. Some of these romances had been painful. We didn't want to be reminded about what we or our friends had done... at least not most of us.
As I was driving in Houston, I heard David Crowder sing this song again. I waited for the "sloppy wet kiss," but I didn't hear it. I was confused, so I looked up the song to see what the problem was. I found this video of David Crowder's official version, which says "unforeseen kiss" instead of "sloppy wet kiss." After more searching, I found this blog post from Our Rising Sound that explained David Crowder changed John Mark McMillan's "sloppy wet kiss" line to "unforeseen kiss." McMillan's blog explained that he originally wrote "sloppy wet kiss" because he saw heaven and earth meeting suddenly, beautifully, and messily. Many of the comments on these two blog posts approved of the original lyrics and did not like how David Crowder changed them. I can appreciate the original meaning. However, I believe David Crowder made the right move. Many people use Crowder's music for group worship, and I do not believe "sloppy wet kiss" is appropriate for most group worship for reasons I've already explained. For me, group worship is supposed to be a prayer for everyone in the crowd. If there are people in the crowd not comfortable with the lyrics (perhaps because for them the lyrics equate God with a creepy uncle or an ex-girlfriend/ex-boyfriend), then the music leader should use different lyrics.
Since I said I don't like most contemporary Christian music, I thought I'd share an older hymn that I do like. I recently discovered "How Firm a Foundation" by John Rippon (1751-1836), and I absolutely love these lyrics. I especially like the line, "The flame shall not hurt you; I only design your dross to consume and your gold to refine." I'm not sure if we didn't sing this hymn growing up in church or if I just don't remember it. Nevertheless, I'd rather sing music like this than most contemporary music, though I do like singing hymns in contemporary style (with guitars instead of an organ).












